@PirateSoftware

Hey look, a video talking about this video:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PTxyu_p1qkc

This situation apparently has an insane number of conspiracies around it ranging from...

1. That's not even what started this! 
The tweets that started all of these were these two here.
https://x.com/godotengine/status/1839656658932306395
https://x.com/voxybuns/status/1839662806053818380
This is legitimately a low-tier joke post and not scary at all.
They weren't in the video because this is milquetoast at best.
The fact that all of this spiraled out of this post is absurd.

2. The guy who was the "Titanium Level Backer" was banned for telling them to keep out of politics. 
No, he was banned for spamming it across multiple social medias including their Discord.
No other "financial backers" have been reported as banned. 
It's all the same image being passed around of the same ban.
Every post states this as a plural "bans" yet it all goes back to the same singular ban.

3. Godot Cafe is the official Discord. 
No, it's actually https://discord.gg/godotengine as shown on their website.
They used to have no official Discord but now have had one since June 2024.

4. They banned tons of people from the Github including that backer!
Then why does he say he wasn't banned from Github here? https://x.com/LifeArtStudios/status/1840388220900544717
Why do all of the posts from locations like this just show a generic ban image with no names? https://x.com/Pirat_Nation/status/1840374511981482433
The only things that can be found regarding this are troll issues opened on the official git like this. https://github.com/godotengine/godot/issues/97700

5. They banned the creators of Godot!
The creators are ​Juan Linietsky ( https://x.com/reduzio ) and Ariel Manzu ( No Twitter )
Juan turned off his Twitter due to the US election cycle and operates on Mastodon.
He talks about it there and also dislikes the attacks on Godot.
Neither were banned and there is no evidence of such.

6. Godot is using emails from their contact form to ban people from the Git repo!
No, this didn't happen at all and there is no evidence of such.
Really insane take to be honest.

Bullshit around this has traveled faster than anything else.
All of the fact checking above was done by me after the video came out.
Literally had no idea this much misinformation about the subject had been brewing.
People playing telephone game with outrageous statements and taking them as truth.
I went through the comments and removed all of the "It came to me a dream" garbage as well.
Going to record another video about this tonight because goddamn.

@jamescombridgeart

What I learned from this: from now on I will call my birth place my spawn point.

@DrakGamestein

Folks on Twitter are allergic to 2 things:
1. Nuance
2. Grass.

@AHeinermann

From what I understood, the Twitter drama happened first, then people went digging after the fact to find that mod stuff.

@mirabilis

Stop being so well-informed.

@ajdndbdjbdj

Aight buddy hold your horses
There was a community manager on twitter that  stated a slightly controversial topic, and then a guy told them simply to focus on the engine, and he got the hammer ban, and he was a Platinum supporter for godot too, and then turns out the manager banned alot of other people that also had the aame issue

@chaoslord8918

1:47 "AoE friendly fire." Finally, someone explained this in terms I can understand.

@Xambaloris

"This is a nothing burger" If I heard it right. I loved it so much that'll add it to my vocabulary, thank you.

@Jeuxetgobelins

Morale of that story: twitter is a silly place.

@ArcadiaCv

I hope everyone keeps in mind that while Thor often times speaks with a lot of confidence, at the end of the day he's just a person and can get the facts wrong just like anyone else. I think it's highly unlikely he's purposely trying to gaslight us on what happened.

@itsnotborker456

Correct me if I'm wrong, but godot Cafe used to be the official discord that was linked on the website until they made the current one(and was still linked). Sounds clearly like an endorsement to me.

@ttrev007

This was not an accurate summary of what happened. it started on twitter where their was a post that some people thought was political (it literally had the word woke in it, but was not the end of the world), when people asked them to reframe from being political they went on a banning spree. Banning anyone who said anything about it, even if they were polite about their request. then on the unofficial discord the Xanax (don't know the spelling) went on a very hateful rant (his rant was pretty bad). the unofficial discord was the official one until very recently and has very strong connection to Gadot including common moderators and is promoted on their website. the Gadot group then apologized about the banning spree and asked people to contact them to be unbanned. But, in the request they gave out to be unbanned they asked for emails and used the emails to ban people from the repository.

I don't think the initiating tweet would have been a big deal if they had not gone on a banning spree and then doubled down with the repository bans. They have also not done anything to distance themselves from Xanax (not sure of the spelling), but i think that was a secondary issue to the banning.

@EmberTheShark

The head people behind godot 100% stood behind this mod. Ergo it does not matter what discord this mod operates in.

@coffeehousephilosopher7936

"Majority of angry Twitter don't even make stuff, who gives a shit."  That's such a fire quote,  especially since this would save people so much time and energy.

@alphacode5

this started as a silly twitter moment but ended up with people actually being unable to access the official godot repo because of a power trip of a single person and that's a little more messed up. don't mess with the openness of open source

@phitsf5475

This is probably why employment contracts tend to have some sort of clause saying you can't talk shit online

@NG.Cha0s

I miss live and let live, treat others as you want to be treated, to each their own. Basically just everything I was taught growing up in the 90s.

@araqweyr

Sorry Thor, but I have to disagree with you about what has happened. I saw events unfold in real time. Godot Official account made a stupid tweet mocking another stupid tweet (saying that all games made with game engines are woke) which had little to none likes (so nobody even agreed with it). A lot of people said either "no politics" (including identity politics) or "just focus on the engine". Or both. Including one Titanium level backer. He and many-many others were banned. Which caused outrage, which caused more bans, etc. CM and xananax's messages just fueled the fire, but they were not the source. Godot founder wasn't at fault either. He played neutrality back then, but after dust has settled he said he supports CM on his Mastodon account. People were also banned for posting quotes of him btw. And the last piece - people also didn't like their complete non apology. Godot foundation framed the events as if was targeted harassment attack by bigots and didn't take any accountability for actions of their CM
Edit: I forgot Starkium is a Titanium level backer. Not platinum. Fixed it.
Edit 2: No Thor, this is not a conspiracy. I'm not blind nor illiterate. I know what I saw

@silverlight6074

And then Redot happened, and their discord definitely wasn't brigaded by people angry over the idea of "hey we just want to make the game engine better"

@glydstudios5632

This was kinda half true. They advertised that discord on their website and the same people who said gross shit were also mods on the official subreddit.